|
|
||||||||
Research Reports |
W Ter Woerds, MSc, is a medical student at Department of Physiology, Radboud University Nijmegen Medical Centre, Nijmegen, the Netherlands
PCE De Groot, PhD, is Post-Doctoral Fellow, Department of Physiology, Radboud University Nijmegen Medical Centre, PO Box 9101, 6500 HB, Nijmegen, the Netherlands
DHJM van Kuppevelt, MD, is Physician, Rehabilitation Centre Maartenskliniek, Nijmegen, the Netherlands
MTE Hopman, MD, PhD, is Associate Professor, Department of Physiology, Radboud University Nijmegen Medical Centre
(p.degroot{at}fysiol.umcn.nl). Address all correspondence to Dr De Groot
Submitted March 3, 2005;
Accepted December 5, 2005
| Abstract |
|---|
Subjects. Eight men with motor complete SCI and 8 male control subjects participated.
Methods. Echo Doppler measurements were obtained to measure leg blood flow at rest, during and after 10 minutes of standardized passive leg movements, and during and after 20 minutes of passive leg cycling. Blood pressure was measured continuously, and total vascular resistance and leg vascular resistance were calculated.
Results. In both groups, no changes in leg blood flow, vascular resistance, or blood pressure were observed during or after the 2 interventions.
Discussion and Conclusion. The results of the study demonstrate that passive leg movements and passive cycling do not alter the arterial peripheral circulation in subjects with SCI or control subjects. Although the results do not support the use of passive movements or exercise for the prevention of cardiovascular diseaserelated secondary complications, physical therapists should not be dissuaded from using these techniques to address musculoskeletal concerns.
Key Words: Blood circulation Spinal cord injuries
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Excessive pressure as well as other factors, such as an inadequate nutrition and impaired circulation,14,15 are risk factors for pressure sores. The elevated vascular resistance in subjects with SCI5 will reduce peripheral tissue perfusion and capillary blood flow further and subsequently contribute to the development of pressure ulcers1416 and to poor wound healing.17
These secondary complications are a frequent cause of morbidity and mortality and lead to a decrease in the quality of life in people with SCI.1820 Moreover, they account for a major part of the treatment costs.21 Therefore, prevention of secondary complications in people with SCI has become an important topic. Previous studies of people with SCI showed that the detrimental adaptations in the circulatory system are partially reversible by functional electrical stimulation training.5,22 Moreover, several studies indicated that passive exercise leads to circulatory2327 and muscular28,29 adaptations in people who are healthy as well as in people with SCI. Possible mechanisms by which passive exercise may enhance leg blood flow (LBF) could be related to activation of the passive muscle pump or ankle pump, of mechanoreflexes, or of the autonomic nervous system.3034 Passive leg movements carried out by a physical therapist and passive cycling are 2 forms of passive exercise frequently used in the rehabilitation of people with SCI. Whether these interventions positively affect the arterial peripheral circulation is unknown. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to assess peripheral circulatory responses during and after passive leg movements and passive cycling in subjects with SCI and control subjects who were healthy by using protocols like those used in the clinical setting in rehabilitation centers. We hypothesized that these passive interventions would enhance LBF in both groups.
| Method |
|---|
|
|
|---|
=8.3, SD=6.1). All subjects were between 20 and 49 years of age and had no history of diabetes, cardiac diseases, recent DVT, or recent pressure ulcers. Two subjects with SCI had a history of DVT 9 years previously; however, the DVT was in the left leg, and all measurements in the present study were obtained in the right leg. Five subjects with SCI had had pressure ulcers in the past (2, 2, 5, 9, and 9 years previously, respectively). Subjects with SCI exercised 5.7±3.9 hours (
±SD) per week, mainly endurance-type exercise, whereas control subjects exercised 4.7±2.3 hours per week. Descriptive characteristics of the study subjects are summarized in Table 1.13
|
Protocol
Subjects were asked to refrain from use of caffeine, alcohol, and nicotine 12 hours before testing and not to perform exhaustive exercise 24 hours before testing. The tests were performed between 8:30 AM and 1:00 PM. All measurements were obtained in a room in which the temperature was kept constant at 23.5° to 25°C. The same investigator performed the test procedures, and passive leg movements were applied by 1 physical therapist in exactly the same sequence and manner for all subjects.
Successively, each subject underwent 2 interventions, which consisted of passive leg movements and passive cycling. The control subjects were instructed to relax the muscles of the lower extremities during both experiments. To ensure that the control subjects did this, myofeedback (Myomed 432*) was used during passive cycling. The myofeedback device gave audiovisual feedback from the activity levels of the rectus femoris muscle and the vastus lateralis muscle of the quadriceps femoris musculature. During passive leg movements, the physical therapist detected muscle contractions manually and gave verbal feedback to the control subjects. The entire procedure was practiced before testing began.
Passive leg movement protocol
Subjects were studied in the supine position. The protocol consisted of 3 parts: 20 minutes of rest, 10 minutes of passive leg movements, and 10 minutes of recovery. During the intervention, the right leg was passively moved according to the protocol shown in Table 2. Passive movement therapy was performed in a standardized sequence with similar durations for the different movements and with the same intensities of stretching by the experienced physical therapist. For all movement patterns, the full range of motion was applied. Two subjects in the SCI group had a limited range of motion; that is, 1 subject had a maximum flexion angle in the knee joint of 115 degrees (normal: ±160°), and 1 subject had a range of motion in the ankle joint of 40 degrees (normal: ±70°).
|
).
Passive cycling protocol
After the passive leg movements, the subjects moved actively from the supine position to the sitting position and transferred over a distance of 1.5 m to the bicycle. During passive cycling, the subjects were seated in a wheelchair or a standard chair in front of the cycle ergometer (Reck Motomed Viva I
). After 20 minutes of rest, the subjects cycled passively for 20 minutes, followed by a 10-minute recovery period. Passive cycling was performed on an electrically driven bicycle ergometer at a speed of 35 repetitions per minute. The feet of the subjects were attached to the pedals with Velcro
, and the legs were secured just below the knee. Subjects were allowed to rest against a back support. For measurements during passive cycling, the ergometer was stopped briefly (approximately 10 seconds) in the maximally extended leg position. The location at which the femoral measurements were obtained was marked to ensure rapid measurements. Blood flow in the right leg was measured at the end of the 20-minute rest period, after 1 minute of cycling, and subsequently every 2.5 minutes during cycling. During recovery from cycling, measurements were performed at 0, 1, 2, 5, and 10 minutes. The diastolic and systolic diameters of the common femoral artery were measured at rest (ie, immediately before initiation of passive cycling) and at 1 and 10 minutes during recovery (ie, after passive cycling). Blood pressure and heart rate were recorded continuously with the Portapres device.
Measurements and Data Analysis
Red blood cell velocities and the systolic and diastolic diameters of the right common femoral artery were measured by Doppler sonography (Megas Esaote||) with a 5- to 7-MHz linear transducer. Measurements in the common femoral artery were obtained below the inguinal ligament, about 2 cm proximal to the bifurcation into the superficial and profundus branches, and the angle of inclination was consistently below 60 degrees. During every measurement of red blood cell velocities, 2 images were stored, for a total of 6 to 8 velocity profiles. For diameter measurements, 2 images each were frozen at the peak systolic phase and the end-diastolic phase. Off-line, 1 investigator who was unaware of group assignment (SCI or control) or measurement intervention (passive movement or passive cycling) analyzed all velocity profiles and arterial diameters.
The velocity profiles were traced manually, and an average of these velocity profiles was calculated for mean red blood cell velocity. For diameter, 3 measurements were obtained manually from each arterial diameter image, and average values were calculated. Lumen diameter was defined as the distance between the far wall boundary, that is, the lumen-intima interface, and the near wall boundary, corresponding to the media-adventitia interface. The reproducibility of the echo Doppler measurements in our research was reported previously,6 and the coefficients of variation for vessel diameter and blood flow measurements for the common femoral artery were 1.5% and 8%, respectively.
The mean diameter was calculated as one third of the systolic diameter plus two thirds of the diastolic diameter; the resulting value was used to calculate the cross-sectional area (0.25x
xmean diameter squared). Mean LBF (in milliliters per minute) was calculated as mean red blood cell velocity (in meters per second) times cross-sectional area (in meters squared) times 6x107. Leg vascular resistance (LVR) (in millimeters of mercury per milliliter per minute) was calculated as mean arterial pressure (MAP) divided by LBF. For these calculations, we assumed that central venous pressure was low and remained constant throughout the protocol.
Heart rate and blood pressure were measured with the Portapres device. A finger cuff was attached to the third finger of the right hand. Data were collected beat to beat at a rate of 100 Hz. The MAP was computed as the true integrated mean of systolic and diastolic pressures. Previous studies36,37 showed that the Portapres device accurately reflects arterial blood pressure. Modelflow, a pulse-counting method, was used to calculate stroke volume38 and, subsequently, cardiac output (CO)=stroke volume (SV) x heart rate, in liters per minute, and total peripheral resistance (TPR) (MAP/CO, in millimeters of mercury per milliliter per second).
Previous studies on SCI showed that with functional electrical stimulation, blood flow values increased more than 350%.39 In people who are healthy, leg exercise may increase blood flow more than 10-fold.40 In the current literature, inconsistent results have been reported regarding the effects of passive movements on blood flow, with only 1 study showing an increase24 and other studies reporting no effect.41 We hypothesized that, if there is an effect, it would be relatively small, because passive exercise involves no active muscle contractions. A 20% to 40% increase would be clinically relevant, because values in the presence of SCI would approach values for resting flow in the control subjects. Therefore, on the basis of power analyses, we included a total of 8 subjects with SCI and 8 control subjects in the present study (a 20%40% increase in LBF with a standard deviation of 60 mL per minute during exercise can be considered clinically relevant; with
=.05, power is .80, and the number of subjects needed is 8). A Student t test for independent groups was used to test for differences between groups with regard to demographic and baseline circulatory characteristics.
For the variables LBF, LVR, TPR, MAP, and CO, 2-factor repeated-measures analyses were applied with time (rest, intervention, and recovery values) as the within-subject factor and group (SCI and control) as the between-subject factor. The level of statistical significance for all tests was set at P<.05. Data are presented as mean ± standard deviation unless otherwise stated.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In order to compare the subjects with SCI with the control subjects, it was necessary for the control subjects to relax their muscles during the interventions. During passive cycling, myofeedback was used to achieve this goal. With audiovisual feedback, it appeared to be possible to correct the contractions immediately. During passive leg movements, the physical therapist was able to sense muscle contractions manually and to correct them by means of verbal feedback. Normally, when muscle activity is present, cortical brain activity causes autonomic nerve activity and a subsequent increase in heart rate.42 In the present study, heart rate did not increase; therefore, all subjects were assumed to be in a passive state.
| Resting Properties |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Passive Leg Movements and Passive Cycling |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Muraki and colleagues23,46 studied passive cycling in subjects with SCI and reported an increase in SV and CO. These results may suggest that it is possible to enhance LBF by use of passive cycling, through enhancement of MAP as a result of an increase in CO. However, in the present study, we found no changes in LBF during passive exercise. Apparently, an increase in CO during passive cycling may not imply that LBF will increase. A possible explanation for the findings of Muraki and colleagues may be related to the body position during their experiments. In that study, a normal bicycle ergometer was used, whereas in our study, subjects were seated in a wheelchair in front of a cycle ergometer. This difference is a major one, because in a sitting position on a standard bicycle ergometer, the lack of back support requires more muscle activation of the trunk and upper extremity. It is well known that the splanchnic area contains a major portion of the total blood volume and that the activation of, for instance, abdominal muscles may cause an increase in venous return. Through the Frank-Starling mechanism, this scenario may provoke an increase in SV. Moreover, static muscle activation results in increased oxygen demand and a subsequent increase in CO.
Unfortunately, Muraki and colleagues reported no information regarding the activity of muscles in the upper part of the body. They did measure skin blood flow in the lower limbs by laser Doppler imaging during passive cycling and reported no increase in skin blood flow. This finding is in agreement with the lack of changes in the peripheral circulation during passive exercise in the present study. Because we could not detect an effect of passive exercise on peripheral blood flow, tissue perfusion will not be enhanced during or after passive exercise. Tissue perfusion and related capillary blood flow are low in people with SCI and with impaired circulation in the lower part of the body5; low perfusion and low blood flow represent risk factors for pressure ulcers and poor wound healing.16,17
During active exercise, neural control of the cardiovascular system is believed to encompass 2 major mechanisms.33,42 The first mechanism is called central command. Signals arising in a central area of the brain activate the motor cortex and, in a parallel fashion, activate the cardiovascular control areas in the medulla. This activation causes autonomic nervous system reactions, such as vagal withdrawal at the onset of exercise and a subsequent increase in heart rate. This mechanism serves as a feed-forward system that is related to the volitional component of exercise and therefore will not be activated by passive exercise.
The second mechanism is based on the activation of cardiovascular control areas in the medulla by afferent information from chemoreceptors and mechanoreceptors in skeletal muscle. Chemoreceptors are activated whenever blood flow to the muscle is restricted, so that the delivery of oxygen and the washout of metabolites are reduced. Because no increase in oxygen consumption and no production of metabolites occur during passive exercise, afferent signals from chemoreceptors will not play a role in the control of the cardiovascular system. The mechanoreflex is a feedback control mechanism, evoked by mechanical stimuli caused by passively moved muscles and joints.31,33,47 In people with SCI, peripheral afferent reflexes are absent, because there is a disruption of the afferent pathway. Therefore, chemoreflexes as well as mechanoreflexes do not play a role in cardiovascular responses during passive exercise in people with SCI. In people who are healthy, however, it is possible that mechanoreflexes influence the cardiovascular system during passive exercise.
Another theory that has been postulated to explain possible cardiovascular changes caused by passive movements is the passive muscle pump, in analogy to the active muscle pump.31,48 According to this theory, rhythmic lengthening and shortening of muscles can induce cardiovascular responses because of increased venous return. In accordance with the Frank-Starling mechanism, an increase in venous return results in a subsequent increase in SV. A mechanism that is comparable to the passive muscle pump is the so-called ankle pump, in which the displacement of tendons may bring about a sucking action of deep and superficial veins underlying these tendons.30,34
Because the central command and chemoreflexes are absent, only the passive muscle pump and the ankle pump could have induced cardiovascular changes during passive exercise in the subjects with SCI. Finally, it is possible that in the subjects with SCI, autonomic dysreflexia may have been induced by the passive exercise intervention. However, arguments against this theory are that there was no effect on LBF or MAP of any of the interventions and that, moreover, we did not observe any differences in responses between subjects with lesions high in the thoracic area and those with lesions low in the thoracic area.
In the present study, no changes in the peripheral circulation during passive exercise were found; therefore, we conclude that the passive muscle pump or the ankle pump, the mechanoreflexes, and the autonomic nervous system are not sufficient to enhance local blood flow during passive exercise. Although the results of this study do not support the use of passive movements or exercise for the prevention of cardiovascular diseaserelated secondary complications, physical therapists should not be dissuaded from using these techniques to address musculoskeletal concerns.
| Conclusion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
TNO-TPD Biomedical Instrumentation, Meibergdreef 9, 1105 AZ, Amsterdam, the Netherlands. ![]()
Eureva, Saturnusstraat 95, 2516 AG, Den Haag, the Netherlands. ![]()
Velcro USA Inc, 406 Brown Ave, Manchester, NH 03103. ![]()
|| Pie Medical Benelux BV, Philipsweg 1, 6227 AJ Maastricht, the Netherlands. ![]()
Dr De Groot, Dr van Kuppevelt, and Dr Hopman provided concept/idea/research design. Mr Ter Woerds and Dr De Groot provided writing and data collection. Mr Ter Woerds provided data analysis. Dr Hopman provided project management and fund procurement. Dr van Kuppevelt provided subjects and facilities/equipment. The authors acknowledge the participation of all subjects in the study.
The Medical Ethical Committee of the Radboud University Nijmegen Medical Centre, the Netherlands, approved this study.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |